Industrial Music forum » Music news discussion forum

Leave it in the past.

(122 posts)
  • Started 2 years ago by S80
  • Latest reply from Eric Christian

  1. "Virtually nobody wakes up one morning and says "you know what? I'm gonna start an industrial band, get real popular and my CD's are gonna go platinum and I'm gonna tour the world"."

    In fact, many of them had this idea in mind exactly. Hence why we have so many copy-cat sounds and uninspired drivel flooding the club playlists, especially in the last ten years. There was some illusion of rock-star-dom that bands were convinced they could obtain by dominating the DAC. Unfortunately, attention on the DAC did not always pan out into album sales or dedicated fans. It is a faulty system for measuring success.

    "what would people like Bill Leeb, Trent Reznor or Cevin Key do when they heard some new music? If they liked it they would probably buy it, if they didn't they would keep their mouths shut"

    Like Xaos mentioned an example, you do not know those artists very well. I recall hearing interviews back in the Pigface days where everyone would sit around talking shit about other bands. Do you think Bill broke away amicably with Skinny Puppy? Trent moved away from Pigface with the other guys full support? It is funny you mention those artists in particular, as they also dislike the direction "industrial" music has headed. Read some interviews and if you get a chance talk to some of them face to face. The only difference between them and people around here is that we post our opinions on Side-Line in order to get some reaction and start a debate. It has always been like this really, and in fact a good bit of criticism can bring a perspective to a band that really thought they could do no wrong. A certain amount of humility is important to the integrity and direction of industrial music.

    `michael

    Posted 2 years ago #
  2. Reminds me of the SPIN article from back in the 90s when it looked like industrial was set to go mainstream. In an interview, Trent called FLA "boring, monotonous, uninspired bullshit", and Leeb responded by writing a letter that stated "Nine Inch Nails is to industrial what New Kids on the Block are to rap."

    I can't recall off the top of my head if it was in the same article, but I also remember Trent saying at one point that Skinny Puppy fans didn't like him because he "can actually write a song."

    Yeah, well I stand corrected then. I wasn't reading Spin magazine then probably just Industrial Nation which BTW still owes me 2 years more of issues lol...

    Anyway, I guess my point is trying to classify and compare pop music to underground music is pointless. The scene is so small and the interest so shallow that its probably better to just listen to what you like and ignore what you don't like as opposed to dissing it online which is really easy to do.

    Posted 2 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.