Pirate Bay upload by Dependent founder a hoax - 'extensive research not always an option' Internet media sayPosted on 12/02/08
Dependent label owner Stefan Herwig has sent us the following announcement regarding the news that he would have decided to upload the complete Dependent catalogue on The Pirate Bay as several online media have falsely reported.
- "Some interesting news reached us at the offices of Dependent on Monday. According to the online magazine Torrentfreaks.com, Dependent Records founder Stefan Herwig had decided to make the entire Dependent back catalogue available for free via the controversial Torrent tracker The Pirate Bay. Despite the fact that this was an obvious hoax - Herwig has long been a vocal opponent of file sharing - dozens of Internet magazines repeated the story, sometimes including the link to the torrent itself.
The reaction of Torrentfreak.com founder and correspondent "Ernesto" was to note that since he has a full-time job, "doing extensive research is not always an option". He had apparently read news of the label's closing on the Dependent web site and taken the Pirate Bay story at face value; the facts that the person pretending to be Stefan Herwig misspelled the name of the label in the original announcement, and that the official label website made no mention of this unusual offer, failed to raise any red flags with either Torrentfreak.com nor any of the other Internet sites which reprinted the story verbatim. The only online source which first attempted to check the veracity of the announcement with Dependent was online music magazine Side-Line.
As evidence for its own credibility, Torrentfreak.com quotes the Guardian UK as calling the site "more reliable than the BBC"."
Posted by B. Van Isacker
Posted by: StefanHerwig on Jun 03, 09 | 11:48 am
I guess the point is to research first, THEN print your story, and not to print your story, be alerted that you are wrong, then correct it and regard it as a hoax - that you produced yourself.
Posted by: DarkVince on Feb 12, 08 | 10:39 pm
"Bring me my gun of itching desire
Posted by: His Holiness, Pope Pathogen XPVIII on Feb 12, 08 | 5:16 pm
I can't believe people actually care enough about this to make it a news item.
Posted by: Side-Line on Feb 12, 08 | 12:46 pm
@ macs : they adapted the article almost every minute + they never checked with Stefan in the first place + the headline they use is clear. You should check your facts first.
Posted by: macs on Feb 12, 08 | 12:18 pm
This was included in the original article:
Posted by: Skinfitz on Feb 12, 08 | 11:36 am
"doing extensive research is not always an option"
More related news :
'Dependence 2010' hits the stores
'Lung Function', a new lifesign for record label Dependent and industrial pioneers Click Click
Dependent announces Septic VIII compilation for September: 'Maybe the best to date'
Dependent on c/o Pop convention: Stefan Herwig participates in panel with German Pirate Party and Mark Chung (Einstuerzende Neubauten)
Dependent reboots the 'Septic' series with volume 8
Dependent reopens its doors in Summer/Fall 2009 and signs Mesh, Front Line Assembly and more
Final 3 releases for Dependent
Free mp3 bundles from Dependent Records
Metropolis goes dependent
Side-Line publishes exclusive comeback interview with Dependent labelboss Stefan Herwig
Today the band's label Alfa Matrix has announced a massive 3CD album set (no 'normal' edition will be available), titled 'Triadic ballet'. (...)
à;GRUMH... member Phillippe Genion not representative enough for city of Charleroi according to mayor Paul Magnette (PS)
(Photo by Giovanni Troilo) Drama in Chareloi, also often called Palermo à la Meuse, where mayor Paul Magnette (PS) is 'shocked' after the World Press Photo Award was awarded to the photo series as made by the Italian photo journalist Giovanni Troilo. (...)
Norway's finest Essence Of Mind have launched a little teaser for their upcoming album, 'The Break Up!', which will be released on April 10th. (...)
Industrial act Freakangel have done quite well recently, not in the most thanks to the very well received album 'The Ones To Fall' which was released in late 2013. (...)
Sopor Aeternus & The Ensemble Of Shadows see double vinyl release for 'Like a corpse standing in desperation' album
Out by early April is the next step in the completion of the Sopor Aeternus & The Ensemble Of Shadows vinyl catalogue with the double vinyl release of the 'Like a corpse standing in desperation' CD. (...)
Today's date is the 24th of February aka 24/2 (for Europeans that is), in other words, it's EBM-day! Each year this is celebrated by many EBM music fans, and some shops go very far to celebrate this. (...)
Side-Line Exclusive : Cronos Titan album missing for 17 years, found again and now to be released February 27th
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR DAILY NEWSLETTER